Few American cities share as deep a connection to a sister city as Omaha does to Carlentini, Sicily. This weekend’s Santa Lucia Festival, now in its second century, is a reflection of that bond.
Over the course of a decade starting in 1900, the Italian population of Omaha exploded from around 500 to more than 2,000. Much of the credit belongs to brothers Giuseppe and Sebastiano Salerno. Born in 1873, Giuseppe was convinced to leave his native Carlentini by brother-in-law Antonio Marfisi.
The Santa Lucia Festival with the statue lit up at night
Photo courtesy of Omaha Exploration
Giuseppe arrived in 1895 and opened a shoe repair shop at 6th & Pierce Street in the area that would become known as Little Italy. He was joined by his brother, Sebastiano, just two years later. He opened a shoe shop of his own in addition to a secondhand clothing store.
By 1904, Sebastiano began working as an agent for a steamship company, tasked with increasing traffic between Sicily and the United States. He convinced family, friends and neighbors to leave everything behind and settle in Omaha. Sicily had long struggled with poverty and political instability, so many were anxious for better opportunities.
The Santa Lucia Hall 8th and Pierce Street
Photo courtesy of Omaha Exploration
In the community, the brothers were referred to as “Benevolent Padrones” or middlemen who helped arrange passage, housing and jobs for immigrant workers. While the padrone system could be exploitative, the benevolent title set them apart, as they were seen as acting in good faith and looking out for their fellow residents rather than strictly profiting off them.
The Santa Lucia Festival in the evening with the cannoli eating contest ready to begin
Photo courtesy of Omaha Exploration
When the Carlentinians arrived, they found temporary housing in rooming houses established by the brothers and jobs arranged at the railroad or meatpacking plants. They also found plenty of familiar faces, as nearly 3,500 residents of the town of 13,000 eventually made their way to Omaha. The brothers also established the Bank of Sicily in 1908, which allowed immigrants to save money to send back home, create businesses or save toward buying a five-room house for $2,000 with just $100 down.
Giuseppe passed away in 1921 after suffering injuries when his automobile was struck by a streetcar. The bank closed in 1924 after overextending itself through risky investments. That same year, the Immigration Act of 1924 ended large-scale Italian immigration to the United States. The last of the Salerno brothers, Sebastiano, was tracked down in California by a disgruntled customer who had lost his savings in the bank’s failure and fatally shot in 1931.
The Santa Lucia Festival with its popular Santa Lucia Band playing
Photo courtesy of Omaha Exploration
Grazia Bonafede Caniglia arrived in Omaha with her husband, Rosario, and their children in 1908. Born in Carlentini in 1865, the mother of six children was a woman of deep faith and attended church daily while her husband operated one of the city’s first Italian bakeries. It would later become its first pizzeria and a steakhouse, while her children went on to open some of the city’s most beloved restaurants including Piccolo Pete’s, Mister C’s, and Venice Inn.
She made it her mission to strengthen the community’s connection to their former homeland while also deepening their faith. She sought to do so with the establishment of the Santa Lucia Festival. Dating back to 1621, it was the town’s most important religious festival. Santa Lucia is the patron saint of sight and the blind.
St. Frances Cabrini Church, the former St. Philomena Church at 10th and William Street where Grazia Bonafede Caniglia prayed each morning
Photo courtesy of Omaha Exploration
In 1925, Grazia and others formed a committee that hosted a ball to raise money for the first Santa Lucia Festival in Omaha. It drew 2,000 people, including Mayor Jim Dahlman. The neighborhood in which Little Italy sits was later named in his honor. For the festival, she envisioned a statue of Santa Lucia. Designed in Italy, she and other volunteers went door-to-door to collect money to pay for it. During the festival, there is a procession of the statue through the streets, starting at St. Philomena’s Church (present-day St. Frances Cabrini) and ending at 6th & Pierce Street. Beloved in the community and well known for her charity work, Grazia passed away in 1931.
It wasn’t until the 1920s that the festival acquired a permanent home at Santa Lucia Hall, 725 Pierce Street. The former fire station was built in 1891 and purchased from the City of Omaha for $1,235. A 2015 restoration replaced the doors, windows and roof and repaired original woodwork, with preservationists incorporating bricks salvaged from demolished Little Italy landmarks including Venice Inn, the Original Caniglia’s Steakhouse and red brick from Seventh Street. The hall also serves as a museum housing historical photos, cultural artifacts and decades of festival banners, and is available as a rental venue with proceeds supporting the festival committee.
Closeup of the Santa Lucia statue and a photo of Grazia Bonafede Caniglia.
Photo courtesy of Santa Lucia Festival Omaha
The Santa Lucia Festival remained at its original location at 6th & Pierce Street from 1925 until 1981, after which it moved several times before returning to Little Italy at 10th & William Street in 2020. Among the city’s oldest summer festivals, it is free to attend and features Italian cuisine including a Sicilian-style pizza by the Pizza Boys of Santa Lucia, as well as sausage and peppers, meatball sandwiches, mostaccioli, gelato, cannoli and more.
Activities include a bocce ball tournament, live music by the Santa Lucia Band and others, dancing and a fun zone for the kids. The festival concludes on Sunday with the traditional procession of Santa Lucia through the neighborhood and an evening fireworks display.
The Santa Lucia Festival during the day
Photo courtesy of Omaha Exploration
What makes the Santa Lucia Festival unique is that while the saint is from Sicily, most Americans associate the tradition with Sweden, as her feast day falls near the winter solstice. Her name, which derives from the Latin word for light, made her a perfect fit to represent the return of the sun after the long, dark Scandinavian winters.
Here in Omaha, however, the festival’s deeply Sicilian roots make it one of the most distinctive in the country. In fact, it may be the only place in the country to host a large-scale, multi-day outdoor Sicilian-based Santa Lucia Festival. This may be the biggest impact the Caniglia family has made on Omaha, even more than its famous restaurants.
