The
Right Track
Popularity in rail transit spurs Omaha to revisit idea
from the City Weekly, 10/29/05
In a bustling, mixed-use development somewhere out in suburban
west Omaha, a businessman kisses his wife goodbye as he steps out
of their third-floor condo. After walking downstairs, he stops by
the coffee shop located on the first floor of their building. With
coffee in one hand and a brief case in the other, the man walks
three blocks to the light-rail station. Four minutes later, one
of the regularly scheduled trains picks him up for the 15-mile ride
to his office in downtown Omaha.
Does this sound ridiculous and far-fetched? Its not. Omaha
is indeed a candidate for a rail-based transportation system. Rail
transit is becoming more and more popular across the nation. Large
and medium-sized metro areas from coast-to-coast are building rail-transit
systems or at least studying the possibility. Omaha needs to keep
up in the rail-transit race, because the economic and cultural benefits
are enormous.
Back in the 1970s and 80s, only the mega-cities, like New
York, Chicago and Washington, could justify rail-based mass transit
systems. Other U.S. cities were too suburban, spread-out
and in-love with freeways and automobiles. But as populations continued
to soar, and new housing development occurred further away from
the city center, many Americans started looking back into the city
and seeing possibilities.
Now smaller metropolitan areas, with populations not much bigger
than Omahas, are getting into the rail-transit game. Charlotte,
N.C. (2.07 million in population); Portland, Ore. (2.06 million);
Salt Lake City, Utah (1.56 million); Memphis, Tenn. (1.25 million);
and Little Rock, Ark. (813,000) all have rail-transit systems. With
a metro population of 840,000 and a 50-mile-radius population of
almost 1.2 million, Omaha compares favorably to these communities.
Omaha can justify a rail-transit system.
Before we go much further, some definitions are in order. According
to Omaha Streetcar, an organization advocating rail transit in the
Omaha area, streetcars, light rail and commuter rail would be appropriate
options for Omahas rail-transit future.
Streetcars are steel-wheeled vehicles powered by overhead
wires that usually operate in mixed-street traffic and operate in
single-units only. Streetcars can use modern equipment, similar
to operations in Europe, or use vintage or heritage equipment.
Light rail is an electric railway system characterized
by its ability to operate single or multiple-car systems along exclusive
rights-of-way at ground level, on aerial structures, in subways
or in streets, able to board and discharge passengers at station
platforms or at street, track, or car-floor level. It is normally
powered by overhead electrical wires.
Commuter rail is an electric or diesel propelled railway
for urban passenger train service consisting of local short distance
travel operating between a central city and adjacent suburbs. Such
rail service, using either locomotive hauled or self propelled railroad
passenger cars, is generally characterized by multi-trip tickets,
specific station-to-station fares, railroad employment practices,
and usually only one or two stations in the central business district.
Rail transit makes sense for Omaha. We would probably start out
small, with streetcar lines in the downtown/riverfront area. Then,
we could extend the streetcars to Dundee, North Omaha and South
Omaha. Eventually, we could explore the possibility of a light rail
line that would connect downtown with suburban areas. Eppley Airfield
could be connected to downtown via streetcar or light rail, whichever
made more financial sense.
A number of factors rationalize rail-transit in our community.
Omaha is a growing city, aggressively recruiting new businesses
and people. We are a business town, with lots of commuters on the
go. Omaha is investing in its urban core as evidenced by $2 billion
worth of downtown construction. More than 1,000 new condo units
are under construction in or planned for downtown, which means there
will be a growing pedestrian urban population eager to use streetcars.
Urban neighborhoods outside downtown Omaha are getting attention
too. The Destination Midtown effort is actively improving a 3.5
square mile area just west of downtown. Urban villages,
like Dundee, Benson and South Omaha, are becoming more popular.
Such places make great sites for rail-transit stations.
Omaha is becoming a regional tourist destination. Every year we
add more retail, restaurant and entertainment attractions. The Qwest
Center is bringing in thousands of visitors each year, and a streetcar
system would be very useful in shuttling convention-goers between
the airport, hotels and the convention center. The unusually close
proximity of the Omaha airport and the central business district,
would make a light-rail connection less expensive to build than
it would be in other cities, where airports are located out in the
suburbs.
Though Omaha is not a huge metropolitan area, it does have traffic
congestion. A recent study identified Omaha as one of the nations
most congested mid-sized metro areas. Furthermore, because a disproportionate
amount of Omaha-area development takes place on the western edge,
some new suburban developments are more than 20 miles away from
downtown!
Obviously, there would be challenges to building a rail-transit
system in the Big O. Chief among them would be money. Even the lowest
cost rail-transit option, streetcars, would cost millions of dollars,
but cost issues can be overcome. The federal government pays for
a large chunk of most rail-transit systems. Omahas unique
ability to create strong public-private partnerships could also
help the system become a reality.
Another challenge is the lack of population and population density.
This can be overcome by selecting the right routes. Though Omaha
is only the 58th largest U.S. metro area, it is the 30th most densely
populated one. Certain parts of Omaha are already very dense and
downtown Omaha is developing a great deal of density.
The benefits of having a transit system would more than make up
for the challenges. According to an article in the October 2005
edition of Retail Traffic magazine, rail-transit stations are magnets
for real estate development. It turns out that young professionals
and empty nesters, the same people who love living in downtown condos,
love living in urban developments located along transit lines. In
Dallas, real estate developers are building mixed-use neighborhoods
next to new transit stations. Residents can live in a nice building
in an established urban neighborhood and walk to the transit station.
From there, they can go downtown, to the airport or anywhere else
the system goes. These developments are injecting billions of dollars
into Americas inner cities. Shouldnt Omaha get its share?
Additionally, rail transit in Omaha would be good for economic
development. Companies looking for corporate headquarters locations
like cities with rail-transit, because it makes it easier for employees
to get to work. Because rail transit is considered a quality-of-life
benefit, it helps in recruiting talented people. By connecting a
citys attractions, rail transit makes it easier to recruit
conventions and trade shows. Convention planners take great comfort
in knowing an efficient transportation system is in place to ferry
their conventioneers around town. Rail transit is interesting and
unique, so people see it as a fun and enjoyable way of moving about
town. Thats good for tourism.
Finally, rail transit would bring the benefits of cleanliness and
efficiency to Omaha. For every person who takes rail-transit, there
is a corresponding decrease in the amount of air pollution. More
importantly, for most people, it saves money. With the price of
gasoline going out of control, the thought of rail transit is appealing
especially for those on a tight budget. Thirdly, a rail system would
decrease traffic congestion. Omaha will continue to grow and will
someday be a significantly larger city. We need to plan for that
growth now if we dont want intolerable grid-lock in the future.
Fortunately, some Omahans are looking ahead. One such group is
Omaha Streetcar. Anyone interested in learning more about this topic
should consider attending Omaha Streetcars next meeting scheduled
for Wednesday, November 2nd from 6 to 7:30 p.m. at the Spaghetti
Works in the Old Market. The cost is $10.99 per person and covers
dinner. To make a reservation, go to omahastreetcar@gmail.com.
Jeff Beals, vice president of operations for Coldwell Banker Commercial
World Group, hosts a weekly radio talk-show called Grow Omaha,
which focuses on economic development in the Omaha area. It airs
Saturdays at 8 a.m. on KKAR (1290 AM). Beals co-hosts the show with
Trenton Magid.
Level Field 2005-09-22 18:43:21
Osborne says tax incentives put states on equal footing
While participating in the Greater Omaha Chamber of Commerces
trip to Washington, D.C. last week, I found myself in a question-and-answer
session with U.S. Representative Tom Osborne (R-Neb). Although 69
Omaha-area business and political leaders were in the meeting to
discuss federal issues, I couldnt resist asking a state-related
question.
Because Osborne is a candidate for governor of Nebraska, I figured
my question was fair game: Congressman, what is your opinion
of the new tax-incentive package passed by the Nebraska Legislature
earlier this year, and what are your thoughts on the role of tax
incentives in economic development?
Osborne said that tax incentives are necessary tools in order for
a state to be on equal footing with its competitors. The former
Hall of Fame football coach made an athletic analogy. Its
like having a football team thats allowed to give 25 scholarships
per year, but you decide to compete with only 15.
I couldnt agree more. Nebraska is in a perpetual, cut-throat
battle with every other state in the nation and every nation in
the world to attract good jobs. Every state wants new manufacturing
plants, corporate headquarters, research and development facilities
and distribution centers. If Nebraska is going to survive and hopefully
thrive in tomorrows global economy, we must be a tough competitor
today.
Thats why the new Nebraska Advantage business incentive legislation,
passed earlier this year, is so important. Nebraska Advantage incentives
become active on Jan. 1, 2006. Because of the new package, Nebraska
will become far more competitive and much more desirable in the
business recruitment race.
The Nebraska Advantage Act of 2005 (known as Legislative Bill 312)
is a comprehensive package of nearly $200 million in annual business
development incentives designed to give businesses the support they
need to expand, start new ventures, train workers for 21st Century
jobs and develop new products and services.
The package offers incentives for a wide range of business and
development activities. The first of which will make Nebraska much
more competitive in the manufacturing sector. Manufacturing machinery,
equipment and related services are now exempt from local and state
sales taxes.
Overall, the Nebraska Advantage package outlines five tiers of
incentives available to qualifying businesses. Tier one requires
$1 million of new capital investment and the creation of at least
10 jobs. This tier supports small businesses if at least 75 percent
of sales are out-of-state. Companies are eligible for a partial
refund of sales tax paid for their investment, job credits, plus
a three percent investment tax credit.
Tier two requires at least $3 million of new investment and the
creation of at least 30 jobs. Companies at this tier may qualify
for a full sales tax refund for qualified investments in the project,
job credits and a 10 percent investment tax credit. Tier three is
for job creation without an accompanying capital investment. Businesses
that create a minimum of 30 new jobs may qualify to receive jobs
tax credits.
Tier four requires companies to invest at least $10 million and
create a minimum of 100 jobs. These companies receive the credits
outlined in tier two, plus they may qualify for property tax exemptions
for the purchase of certain equipment used in the course of business.
The fifth and final tier is for companies that invest a minimum
of $30 million without the creation of new jobs. These companies
may qualify to receive the full refund of sales taxes on capital
investment in the project.
The term jobs credits is mentioned several times above.
The jobs tax credit in the new package is a sliding-scale credit,
ranging from three to six percent of the average wages of new employees
and is based on an index of the Nebraska average annual wage. If
new jobs average at least 60 percent of the Nebraska wage, the job
credit is three percent. If the new jobs average at least 125 percent
of the annual average wage, the job credit is six percent. These
credits can be used to offset employer withholdings.
Finally, Nebraska has set aside significant funding to support
custom job training. This funding can be used with new job creation
or to retrain an existing workforce learning to work with new technology.
While the details of the package can leave a lay person with blurry
eyes, these incentives are exactly what companies are looking for
when choosing a place to invest and create jobs.
Governor Dave Heineman, who signed the bill into law earlier this
year, summed up its importance: In this global economy, our
entrepreneurs need the tools to compete, he said. The
Nebraska Advantage and its targeted tax credits will help our existing
businesses create good jobs for Nebraskans, but we need to let them
know these opportunities exist. This is an important investment
in good jobs for our children and grandchildren.
While the whole state will benefit from the Nebraska Advantage
business incentive package, Omaha, as the states primary commercial
hub, will benefit the most. Thats intriguing. I have great
optimism for the future of Omahas economy. To that end, I
expect we will hear some exciting economic-development announcements
in the coming year.
Jeff Beals, vice president of operations for Coldwell Banker
Commercial World Group, hosts a weekly radio talk-show called Grow
Omaha, which focuses on economic development in the Omaha
area. It airs Saturdays at 8 a.m. on KKAR (1290 AM). Beals co-hosts
the show with Trenton Magid.
|